Topic: Microsoft goes over the edge. Sues me over $50 software...

Return to Archives of AuctionBytes


Casino Classic
Best Online Casino!
Get $500 free on the house!
Shared Movies
Over 80 Million Movies and TV-Shows
No Charge per movie, No download limit!
Weight Loss Supplements
Natural supplements that burn body fat,
suppress appetite and support a healthy diet.
Antidepressant Medications
Handle stress, elevate the mood,
treat anxiety disorders.


Posted at March 2, 2005, 10:35 pm:

Hello, my name's David Zamos. This is my first time posting here, but I've learned alot from eveyone, especially Karen and Michael- Thanks!

I wanted to let everyone know about a situation that has developed regarding Microsoft and I, and the eBay Vero program thereby. First, is there anyone else whos frustrated with the VERO program's apparent requirment that you fax in all sorts of sensitive information in order to affect a counternotice? The DMCA lists specific elements and specific actions to be taken if those elemnts are included- I don't see how eBay thinks they can unilatterally modify the law... oh well

Anyways I bought Microsoft software that I later learned I couldn't use without some trouble, I guess Microsoft doesn't let XP Pro users to upgrade to XP Home edition without reformating their hardrives!

When I went to return the software to my school, where I bought it, the University of AKron, I was refused- they said Microsoft won't let them accept returns. I then tried to sell off the software on eBay- I clearly stated it was educational software, and hadn't been opened/used. The auctions were cancelled by Microsoft due to some licensing agreement that is apparently presented upon installation of the software, but is not mentioned in any way upon the packaging- and I never installed the software.... One auction ended before the cancellation, however; so I had only one piece of software left.

I then wrote Microsoft a certified mail letter telling them that I didn't know about the license, but rejected it, and wanted to return the software, which was unopened, to them for a refund. They mailed me a response 34 days after signing the return reciept that said they accept returns for up to 30 days after purchase... great, they took longer than that to send me their form letter in response. I have the postmarked return envelope and the return reciept, so I can prove these dates.

Anyways I then counternoticed through the DMCA's provisions to eBay and Microsoft ignored such, even though I sent a copy to their corporate attornies at Covington and Burling, and told them what and why I was doing. They had plenty of time to oppose the auction, which ran for five days after ebay reinstated the auction... which took about 18 days after they recieved the counternotice in the first place.

Finally, I told eBay to remove the records of any naughtiness from my account relating to the first auction they cancelled that had succesfully ended before the cancellation. This auction was completed on the 27th of Sept, and I sent the notice asking for the negative marks to be removed on the first of Dec. Microsoft was apparently confused, despite the fact I specifically and solely refrenced the completed auction, and thought this related to a new auction they had ended.

Apparently not wanting to let silly things like facts and reason get in the way, they filed a lawsuit against me in my federal District Court.

I counterclaimed, citing various deceptive trade practices, holding consumers to licenses they don't know about, and for general nastiness- stipulating that I would settle all counterclaims for an appology for my time, and a decleration that Microsoft has no evidence that I've been manufacturing or duplicating their CD's- which they sorta alluded to in their complaint. I later found out that the complaint they filed was a "form complaint" that their local counsel has filed in many previous actions that did involve illegal duplication. When cutting and pasting my name I guess they forgot to remove these items.

Microsoft refused to accept my "settlment" of $0.00 and an appology, but wanted to drop the whole suit. I refused, and we're currently awaiting our first case managment conference and the begining of discovery.

I've documented some of this silliness at http://www.geocities.com/mymicrosoftlawsuit/titlepage
and would be flattered if anyone wanted to check it out.

Hope someone gets something outa this whole deal! Seriously, the software I purchased cost $50...

As this is non-willful infringment and Iwas unaware of any license when I listed the first auction (and I complied with Microsoft's VERO page's "msnetsafeteam" requirments when I listed the second item after the succesful counternotice) they are limited to recovering actual damages. As they have two law firms and four attornies on this case, these damages might just be a tad less than their legal fees, but I really think an ape could beat this case in court anyways.

In general though, I'm in this for the principle... I don't really have any assets to settle a judgment anyways, and as I'll be entering a doctoral program in two years, I really have no need for decent credit for a long while.... Most Graduate programs provide stipends that are not considered salaries, and so may not be attached, and many provide free housing. Other than that, I own nothing.

Not really afraid of losing anyways though, and looking forward to deposing Microsoft, lol. I'd appreciate any comments

Thanks for reading

Original of the message was taken from http://www.auctionbytes.com/forum/phpBB/

Replies:

Disclaimers are supposed to be displayed where the consumer can see th...

Hi Dave, federal court can be very complicated for the unwary lit...

Fees are not automatically awarded.


Other Topics of AuctionBytes:

eBay Punch Auction... would you bid?

Ruined covers, good records, any value?

Google + eBay-There goes the neighborhood!

eBay Store

Paypal Merchant Account $20.00 a month

Several thousand marbles in local auction

Lids/Bottoms/Parts?

Q. about Domain Names that include "eBay'

Best Offer ...Do you use it?

Hot catagories

Limoges, English Rose

Nigerian Scammers Species Specific???

Paypal Transaction History Unavailable

how many items are actualy sold on ebay?

Quick Question Regarding Copyright and Trademark Concerns

Some Good News For Those That Sell Vintage Clothing

Storing Travel Brochures

Rosary keychain?

Monopolies are bad. Can eBay monopoly be challenged???

2Checkout.com credit card payment system

PAYPAL TRYING TO SCAM IT'S USERS LOWER FEES? WHAT A JOKE!

Damask Nippon?

font codes not working properly on eBay

Excellent Article by Ina!

Live Online Auctions, anyone?

best

Is abebooks.com a decent venue to sell collectible books?

Goodbye eBay, here comes GBuy!

Funny ebay item w/ almost 100,000 visits.

Can anyone identify this Oriental mark?

Bowl identification help

Recent Sales/Finds

Cleaning Records

Happy New Year

FedEx's Dirty Little Secret Ground Insurance/Claims FYI

What the...???? Pyramid PayPal Scam?

Neat Rodent cage

Eastern ONTARIO eBay sellers can now ship to US with US Post

bursley ware orange oriental dragon vase high lustre

eBay Holds 10-cent Listing Day Tuesday, Sponsored by Skype

Zero Cash, A Little Talent and 30 Days

can't find post??

Where can I find on the web what uncorrected proofs are wort

Movie memorabilia sites

Anybody got some rough Feedback Statistics?

Vintage Tribe Clothing


File Sharing Service  Image Sharing Service  Usenet Newsgroups Reader
Guide to Serials and Shows  English Subtitles For DivX Movies  Lyrics Catalogue
Over 5000 Cocktail Recipes  Hot News Archive  Funny Jokes and Anecdotes
Cooking Recipes Catalogue  Cool Online Encyclopedia  Computer Games Cheats
Pets Department  Spam Free Guestbook Service  Medical Catalogue


Free Web Stats