Topic: Steamboy, musings, etc.

Return to Archives of Movie Forums


Antidepressant Medications
Handle stress, elevate the mood,
treat anxiety disorders.
Shared Movies
Over 80 Million Movies and TV-Shows
No Charge per movie, No download limit!
Casino Classic
Best Online Casino!
Get $500 free on the house!
Weight Loss Supplements
Natural supplements that burn body fat,
suppress appetite and support a healthy diet.


Posted at July 29, 2010, 9:04 pm:


Watched Steamboy two weekends ago, for those of you who don't know about it it's the new movie by Katsuhiro Otomo, same guy who illustrated the comic book Akira, and later adapted it to film.

This is only Otomo's third feature length directorial project since he first brought his distinct graphic style to film with Akira in 1988. Prior to that he had been a professional mangaka since around the early-mid seventies. In the manga industry Otomo established himself with his groundbreaking sense of print storytelling in a number of short works - most notably Domu (available in English from Dark Horse comics in trade paperback form), for which he won the Science Fiction Grand Prix, a prize traditionally awarded to narrative literature - that eventually lead into his most famous work in 1982, when he started serializing the Akira manga in Young Magazine.

I'd say besides Akira (movie and comic) and Domu, the best Otomo stuff that's been released in english are his contributions to the anthology films Neo Tokyo and Memories, and a rare british collection of manga short stories (also titled Memories).

I have to say Steamboy has a heavy burden in dwelling in the shadow of a movie like Akira. My first impression was that it was kind of disappointing, but the more I think about it I think it's kind of growing on me and I'd definitely like to see it again. The style and setting are "steam-punk" (sounds really dumb) - which I think is partly derived from the reimagined 19th century technology of the 80s series, Nadia: Secret of Blue Water (which itself was derivative of Miyazaki's Laputa).

Actually the main premises behind this bear a striking resemblance to that early Gainax series. In stead of Paris, the young hero (named Ray Steam - wonder what he would have been named if his family worked on internal combustion engines instead) is a Londoner, but the era and anachronistic technology are similar. More importantly they share the same basic plot device: a powerful new technology, sought after by greedy thugs. In Nadia it was a flying rock, this time it's a strange Ball that emits a powerful blast of super-compressed steam by turning a valve.

Consistent with most anime, Steamboy has a fairly convoluted roster of characters and can get very talky and heavy-handed with it's attempts at philosophizing (questions about humanistic "progress", technophiles vs. technophobes etc.), which one feels are half-hearted. A lot of the settings and themes in Steamboy show real promise, but unfortunately it never really develops as science fiction (for lack of any real explanation or understanding of the basic underlying technology - we know it runs on steam, but where does all that steam come from in the first place?).

One complaint I've heard a lot (and this for Akira too) is that the characters all lack depth, but I think that misses the point. As with Otomo's other films, and with his comics, Steamboy is primarilly a visceral experience. To some extent I think the lack of psychology indicates laziness - particularly in one crane-operating villian, who seem to act inexplicably against self-preservation instinct, with no apparent motivation save for his role as a bad guy.

But more often than not, the inertia of these characters works with the formless narrative rather than against it. I would describe them as likeably amoral.

I get the sense that Steamboy, like Akira, exists only to satisfy the excesses of Otomo's imagination, not because he has a worldview or personal story that he wants to get across. As with that earlier film the real power of this lies in the aesthetic, the arrangement and layering of images, frantic pacing - deliberately intensified by the discontinuous shots and jerky character animation - and the unexpected flourishes, as when a massive floating castle suddenly transforms itself in a throwback to the opening sequence from Robot Carnival.

I'm also happy to say that in terms of motion, Steamboy has embraced new technology while at the same time evoking a pleasantly anachronistic, rough-edged style. To fully appreciate the level of detail in this film I think you'll have to see it on a big screen - there are sweeping shots of the teeming London landscape and birds eye views with possibly hundreds of points of animation, as well as some fantastic "camera" movement, but the characters always fit in seamlessly with the background (unlike in the clumsy cg effects of Metropolis).

My one minor complaint about Steamboy's esthetic is the unmemorable, washed out color pallet. It does give the setting a certain sense of openness, but I can't help feeling a little disappointed after the strong use of vibrant, but limited complementary palletes in self-contained shots from Akira and The Order to Stop Construction. A bigger problem is the score, which is the epitomy of orchestral blandness and cheesy fanfare.

I'm not sure how to rank Steamboy. As a story I think it's at best irrelevant, at worst disingenuous, but it's also striking and uniquely cinematic, and I think it's already penetrated my imagination to some extent. It's definitely worth seeing for yourself.


Original of the message was taken from http://www.movieforums.com/community/

Replies:

Thanks for the great review linespalsy.

Awesome review, man.

Thanks so much for the review.

Agreed.

Spot-on review.

Quote: Originally Posted by projectMayhem Spo...

The dub, I felt was merely OK, but that was due more in part to the we...

i heard alot of bad things with this movie therefore i don't think it ...

Quote: Originally Posted by projectMayhem I f...

Quote: Originally Posted by Twain The Piano.


Other Topics of Movie Forums:

WICKED: The Untold Story of the Witches of Oz.

Blade Runner

The Movie Poster Battle

a million little pieces?

MoFo Private Messenging

The H-Man Cometh

The Ten Commandments

Movies You Wished You Lived In

Brokeback To The Future

Mulholland Drive

The what are they thinking Sequel's thread.

HD-DVD/Blu Ray information

Jim Carrey

Urban Dead

Gossip

Mofo Answering Machine

Top Five Favorite Books

Based on a Novel?

Posting on AOL

Forgotten Gems (A place to share movies lost in the mists of time)

Kubrick dvds?

MinionTV's Face Job Game!!

Martin Scorsese's The Departed

11:14

Horror Movies

What Is The Most Disturbing Film?

The Saddest Music In The World

My collection, please rate

Best Sex Scene

New Star Wars Worth It?

Ending for cube

Movies You Avoided Seeing (for various reasons)

Movie Club - The Wrath Of Khan

Trailer Reviews...

win a life time supply of bananas!

Best looking Bond babe

Official Batman 2 Update!!!!

Discworld: Liveaction to hit UK TV

North Korean Misslie Launches


File Sharing Service  Image Sharing Service  Usenet Newsgroups Reader
Guide to Serials and Shows  English Subtitles For DivX Movies  Lyrics Catalogue
Over 5000 Cocktail Recipes  Hot News Archive  Funny Jokes and Anecdotes
Cooking Recipes Catalogue  Cool Online Encyclopedia  Computer Games Cheats
Pets Department  Spam Free Guestbook Service  Medical Catalogue


Free Web Stats