Topic: Martin Scorsese, super genius

Return to Archives of Movie Forums


Casino Classic
Best Online Casino!
Get $500 free on the house!
Shared Movies
Over 80 Million Movies and TV-Shows
No Charge per movie, No download limit!
Antidepressant Medications
Handle stress, elevate the mood,
treat anxiety disorders.
Weight Loss Supplements
Natural supplements that burn body fat,
suppress appetite and support a healthy diet.


Posted at July 26, 2009, 11:12 am:


OK, somehow in all this time I don't believe we've ever had a thread devoted specifically and exclusively to Marty Scorsese.




It's no secret I think he's THE best director around. For me, he hasn't made a "bad" film yet - excluding his Roger Corman entry to Hollywood. He's one of the few filmmakers you can say that about, and he's been making movies for thirty or so years. Some are better than others, of course, but it's remarkable how many are masterpieces of some order.

Personally, I'd rank his filmography thusly...


1. GoodFellas (1990)
GRADE: A+++
2. Taxi Driver (1976)
GRADE: A+++
3. Raging Bull (1980)
GRADE: A+++
4. After Hours (1985)
GRADE: A+
5. The Age of Innocence (1993)
GRADE: A
6. The Last Temptation of Christ (1988)
GRADE: A
7. The King of Comedy (1983)
GRADE: A
8. Mean Streets (1973)
GRADE: A-
9. The Last Waltz (1978)
GRADE: A-
10. Casino (1995)
GRADE: A-
11. The Aviator (2004)
GRADE: A-
12. Bringing Out the Dead (1999)
GRADE: B+
13. Cape Fear (1991)
GRADE: B+
14. Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1974)
GRADE: B+
15. Gangs of New York (2002)
GRADE: B+
16. The Departed (2006)
GRADE: B+
17. Kundun (1997)
GRADE: B
18. New York, New York (1977)
GRADE: B
19. Italianamerican (1974)
GRADE: B
20. American Boy: A Profile of Steven Prince (1978)
GRADE: B
21. "Life Lessons" segment of New York Stories (1989)
GRADE: B-
22. The Color of Money (1986)
GRADE: B-
23. Boxcar Bertha (1972)
GRADE: C-

I didn't include his student films, though I've seen them all too (except for the apparently vanished Street Scenes - not even Scorsese hinmself has a print). The student projects are certainly worth seeing, especially for budding filmmakers, as It's Not Just You, Murray and Who's That Knocking at My Door? definitely show the promise that was about to explode onto contemporary American cinema.

I think GoodFellas, Taxi Driver and Raging Bull are his three masterpieces among masterpieces. After Hours and The King of Comedy are his two best but least-known great works. Sadly more people know The Last Temptation of Christ for the "controversy" around it and haven't even bothered to see it for themselves. The Age of Innocence was somehow largely overlooked in the early '90s and richly deserves to be rediscovered. Kundun and Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore also have the potential to reach so many people, but maybe all three of those movies are relatively ignored because they don't seem to fit into the Scorsese canon...at least as most people perceive it? The Last Waltz is the greatest concert film ever made, and weather you know or like the music of The Band and Dylan and Clapton and the rest of the guests or not, watch the film and you'll probably become and instant fan. Mean Streets has been a bit eclipsed by his later work, but it's a gem waiting to be uncovered, and an amazing "debut" film (not counting the Corman exploitation quickie Boxcar Bertha, which even manages to signal some of the visual strengths that would quickly become his trademark). New York, New York was bashed, I think unfairly, by critics upon release and never had a chance to find it's audience. Cape Fear is Scorsese's Touch of Evil, a master having so much fun playing with genre. The Color of Money for me is his least ambitious and ordinary movie, but that being said his stylistic touches are brilliant, the performances are a treat, and even the "least" of Scorsese's work is better than most directors' "best" stuff.


Anywho, what else to say? As a filmmaker I find him an expert craftsman, a complex and emotional storyteller, a master of mood and tone and music, a visual virtuoso who's style doesn't overwhelm the characters but magnifies them, he coaxes consistently flawless performances form the actors he works with, and all with an intenstity and power that can still have surprising moments of humor - that's right, he's funny...like a clown...he amuses me.

Apart from his filmmaking, he's also the perfect ambassador for the craft and magic of the movies. He has been a tireless agent for the preservation and restoration of film since the '70s, a true champion of the medium. His passion for the art is palpable and contagious, one could say it even borders on mania. He has a depth and width of knowledge that is astounding, like an idiot savant of all things cinematic.

Put simply, he is The Man.


So that's my opening ramble. What are everybody's thoughts on Scorsese? Their likes and dislikes. Rate what you've seen, confess what you haven't. What were you blown away by, what made you scratch your head, what have you not even heard of?


And for anyone who considers themself a fan of the man, try your hand at my quiz on this site, HERE.


Original of the message was taken from http://www.movieforums.com/community/

Replies:

I think we could close this thread now and it would be perfect.

Mmmmm, that's what I forgot to rate as well, the two documentaries he ...

I've seen pieces of Taxi Driver and Cape Feare on television, but it's...

Great thread.

I really enjoyed Bringing Out The Dead [what a moron I am; I've seen B...

Perhaps my "favorite" Scorsese movie, or at least the one I'...

Nicely said Holden.

The King of Comedy was pretty badly trashed by critics and audiences a...

My dream packaging for a deluxe LD, well now a DVD, would be an After ...

Unforunately so.

Yeah, the bits of Rupert Pupkin in his basement "practicing"...

My shot.

Raging Bull is a difficult movie to take in.

This is such a geek thread for geeks.

We can't ignore Travis Bickle.

I don't think I said we would.

I never said you did.

Did so.

My favs.

The only true re-make Scorsese has done to date is Cape Fear, from a p...

Question, Pikey.

Spielberg's Schindler's List is a powerful, earnest and important film...

Of Scorsese's post-GoodFellas movies, it is probably fair to say that ...

Bringing Out the Dead was certainly underrated, misunderstood and even...

Well, I knew about Kundun and The Age Of Innocence.

"A love story is like a song: it's beautiful while it lasts.

Great news.

What holidays? Wallabe Freedom Day?

Easter vacation, Chumps.

In 1978, Scorsese decided to get together with a few friends and make ...

Jesus, I had no idea.

Anybody caught the new American Express television commercial starring...

oh yeah.

Quote: Originally posted by Holden Pike Anybody ...

I love the look he gives the clerk after he says, "It's pretty&qu...

Just determining my favourites again.

Martin Scorsese - King Missile This one' called Martin Scorsese H...

****ed up poem dude.

Quote: Originally Posted by marlowe203 ****ed...

I read a magazine interview with Michael Chapman today (Were he and I ...

Yup, that does it.

I'm glad I read this thread through again.

Oh, believe you me, I could.

Quote: Originally Posted by The Silver Bullet ...

Ah, you know.

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike Perha...

Quote: Originally Posted by nebbit Thanks for...

After Hours will always have a special place in my cinema-loving heart...

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike After...

*Bump* The boxed set has arrived folks, and last night I took in Af...

when i first got the box set i thougth After Hours would be my least f...

How do you feel about Alice? There is a scene filmed in a small town I...

Just ran across this review.

No, I haven't read it.

Any person? Hey, you know better than that Some of the folks that co...

Me too i still haven't see alot of his films which i must rent.

Quote: Originally Posted by Sedai How do you ...

Quote: Originally Posted by MichaelMyers i st...

i recently saw Gangs of New York (d.

Good idea.

Quote: Originally Posted by Sedai Good idea.

even though i dont like changing the disk i kind of like the 2 disk mo...

Quote: Originally Posted by Zzat i recently s...

Quote: Originally Posted by Parky Disc switch...

Quote: Originally Posted by Zzat what are you...

Holden, this is one of the best articles I've read of yours yet.

i just finished watching Alice Doesn't Live here anymore and i loved i...

Requests: review of The Last Waltz

The Last Waltz is, quite simply, the best rock & roll conceret doc...

you are my hero holden

Thankyou.

Happy Birthday Martin Scorsese!!!

Bump Also.

Tomorrow (June 14, 2005) sees the release of a new R1 Casino SE DVD to...

Yet another post I would just love to include in the new review system...

Quote: Originally Posted by Sedai Yet another...

Thanks for responding, anyway.

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike Tomor...

Meanwhile, Holden has already rated all the Scorsese films, right here...

I figured I’d update my list in this thread since so many of the newer...

It's nice to see Alice all the way up there, Slay.

Alice.

Yeah, Alice blew me away so completely that I fell in love with the da...

I've seen two Scorsese films recently, The Aviator and The Last Tempta...

Quote: Originally Posted by Piddzilla .

Quote: Originally Posted by LordSlaytan My me...

I watched Disc II of the Raging Bull : SPecial Edition last night.

Genius.

Bump Best thread ever.

Quote: Originally Posted by The Silver Bullet ...

Raging Bull, A+Taxi Driver, A+Goodfellas, A+The Last Temptation of Chr...

I guess I'll take a shot at ranking my man Marty, as well.

Taxi DriverGoodfellasThe King of Comedy Raging Bull CasinoMean Streets...

Quote: Originally Posted by Sedai Day-Lewis' ...

While I haven't seen that much of Scorsese's work (cursed R4 zone!) I ...

the academy should hang it's head in shame for never giving him an osc...

While many call the 1970s his best era (personally, I don't know why -...

Oh, by the by.

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike You...

*envy* Anyway, one other thing I've been wondering - what would it ...

Happy early Birthday Holds! Say hi to Marty for me

I'm going to play Devil's Advocate here.

Quote: Originally Posted by The_Elephant_Man ...

I liked Taxi Driver, and Last Temptation.

Raging Bull is one of my all-time favorites, but on the whole, I think...

Quote: Originally Posted by Purandara88 Ragin...

Most of his films with DeNiro have the feel of improvisation about the...

Quote: Originally Posted by Purandara88 He's ...

Quote: Originally Posted by Tacitus You're tr...

suppossedly he used to act??? i know it aint him, but just to be sure ...

Quote: Originally Posted by kingkong159 suppo...

Goodfellas.

Mean Streets (1973) "You don't make up for your sins in the Ch...

I love Mean Streets, but Wong Kar-Wai's remake (As Tears go By) is per...

Never seen mean streets but looks like its going to be next on my list...

I feel bad for the man, because he hasn't been properly recognized by ...

Quote: Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch I f...

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike Hitch...

I don't think to most mainstream Oscar voters of the old guard that Sc...

Quote: Originally Posted by Holden Pike I don...

Thanks for the great info Pikey

The Departed RELEASE DATE: October 6th, 2006 DIRECTOR: Martin Scor...

Thanks Pikey The trailer looks good

I'm kind of getting sick of people getting excited over Scorsese's new...

Quote: Originally Posted by IchibanKurosawa I...

Quote: Originally Posted by Golgot Edit -...

Quote: Originally Posted by IchibanKurosawa I...

I hope I say, "The Departed was bomb diggady'" when I leave ...

Quote: Originally Posted by IchibanKurosawa I...

I'm not saying that they haven't said it was a remake or have tried to...

The Departed (Martin Scorsese) After helping to define the modern g...

Thanks Pikey for the interesting review, it has just stated here, so I...

I really want to see this but Leo is my only "put off".

Yes.


File Sharing Service  Image Sharing Service  Usenet Newsgroups Reader
Guide to Serials and Shows  English Subtitles For DivX Movies  Lyrics Catalogue
Over 5000 Cocktail Recipes  Hot News Archive  Funny Jokes and Anecdotes
Cooking Recipes Catalogue  Cool Online Encyclopedia  Computer Games Cheats
Pets Department  Spam Free Guestbook Service  Medical Catalogue


Free Web Stats